Help to Buy Scheme Review

The Department of Finance has published a review of the Help to Buy Scheme by Mazars. The scheme is intended to assist first time buyers (FTBs) to save for the deposit required to qualify for a mortgage for the purchase of a newly built residential property. The report notes that the scheme is poorly targeted and promotes demand for new housing in a market where there are supply constraints, while highlighting the deadweight associated with the expenditure.

The Mazars report states that, “[t]here are weaknesses in the Help to Buy scheme and it cannot be concluded that it is sufficiently efficient to represent good value for money. Consequently, we conclude that it should be withdrawn. However, now is not the time to do so.” The report recommends an extension of the scheme for two years only, while removing self-builds from the scheme and increasing the minimum mortgage loan-to-value ratio from 70 percent to 80 percent, during which time a move away from a tax expenditure scheme towards a scheme under the direction of the Department of Housing, Planning and Local Government should be facilitated. However, in Budget 2023 the Minister for Finance announced an extension of the Help to Buy scheme, at current rates, to the end of 2024.