News

The Minister of State with responsibility for Company Regulation at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Dara Calleary TD has encouraged businesses to engage on new Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, the CSRD. Read more. Speaking at a recent webinar, Minister Calleary stated “The new rules for sustainability reporting may be challenging at the outset, however, the requirements have been sequenced, whilst still maintaining ambition, to allow companies, and the accounting and audit industry time to understand the new standards, start measuring the relevant data, and deepen the knowledge and skills necessary.” Minister Calleary went on to state his intention to establish and chair a new sub-group of the Enterprise Forum on Responsible Business that will act as a link with industry and relevant stakeholders and will provide a platform for regular interaction between the Department and its agencies on these important matters. A total of 34 responses were submitted by stakeholders and interested parties on the Member State options contained within the CSRD, ahead of its transposition into Irish law. (The response from Chartered Accountants Ireland can be found here and the Department’s published proposed policy response to the public consultation is here.)

Earlier this year the Dept. of Enterprise Trade and Employment (DETE) sought the views of stakeholders and interested parties on the Member State options contained within the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (EU) 2022/2464, ahead of its transposition into Irish law. 34 responses were received by DETE including one from Chartered Accountants Ireland .A copy of each of the responses is now available on DETE’s website . This week DETE also published its proposed policy response to the public consultation on the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive and readers can access a copy of it here.

The latest KPMG Enterprise Barometer reveals a positive outlook among Ireland's indigenous businesses, with over a third planning workforce expansion. These entrepreneurial firms prioritise sustainability but seek clarity on costs and benefits, says Alan Bromell KPMG Enterprise Barometer 2023 highlights confidence among Ireland’s indigenous businesses, with over half (55 percent) expecting to increase turnover in the next 12 months.  The majority of survey respondents, 83 percent, support the need for more action on climate change, and 7 out of 10 are actively pursuing sustainable measures, demonstrating the proactive approach these entrepreneurial businesses are taking to incorporate environmentally friendly practices into their operations.   The research reveals overall optimism among Irish businesses, with over half (55 percent) expecting to increase turnover in the next 12 months and 38 percent expecting to expand their workforce, demonstrating a belief in their growth potential and job creation. Balancing the costs and benefits of sustainability While the majority of survey respondents support more action on climate change, two-thirds express concern about the need for more clarity on the costs and benefits of these measures, and three-quarters say no stakeholder groups are exerting pressure on them to develop decarbonisation strategies. This poses a significant challenge for companies as they strive to make informed decisions on sustainability measures and allocate resources effectively. The survey showed resilience and measured confidence in the future amongst Irish businesses and entrepreneurs. Notwithstanding the challenges in areas such as costs and interest rates, Irish entrepreneurs are resourceful and robust. Private Irish business and entrepreneurship are critical pillars of the Irish economy, providing employment, sustaining tax revenues and acting as role models for future entrepreneurs. In addition, their ingenuity and innovation can be instrumental in solving various challenges, from technology, health and nutrition to sustainability and environmental protection. The survey also shows that sustainability has become a fundamental aspect of business operations, and it’s encouraging to see businesses in Ireland actively pursuing sustainability measures. However, they need help understanding the costs and benefits of decarbonisation. Tax suggestions for Budget 2024 When asked for their views on the current tax regime, less than a quarter (24 percent) said they believe it encourages entrepreneurship and growth. At the same time, three-quarters feel that the Irish tax regime is more challenging for domestic businesses.  The top three tax changes businesses would like to see in Budget 2024 are introducing tax measures to encourage sustainable behaviour (83 percent), amending capital gains tax rates or rules to encourage investment in Irish companies (79 percent) and introducing a reduced tax rate for dividends for entrepreneurs (74 percent ). These highlight a desire for tax incentives and reforms that promote sustainable business practices, stimulate investment and reward entrepreneurship. Recruiting challenges Sixty percent of private Irish businesses and entrepreneurs face difficulties recruiting the right individuals to fill key company positions. Nearly half (45 percent) consider the current tax regime in Ireland a disadvantage to recruiting and retaining skilled employees. The availability of residential accommodation is another primary concern; over three-quarters (77 percent) say lack of accommodation is an issue, suggesting that the housing situation in Ireland could impact recruitment and competitiveness. Alan Bromell is Head of Private Enterprise at KPMG

The Climate Action Framework was approved by the Irish Government in August 2022. Sara McAllister, Partner and Head of Business Risk Services at Grant Thornton, sheds light on its origins and the obligations that organisations must fulfil In August 2022, the Irish Government approved the Climate Action Framework (the Framework) for the commercial semi-state sector. Developed by the New Economy and Recovery Authority (NewERA) in collaboration with the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform and the Department of Environment, Climate and Communications, the Framework applies to all commercial semi-state (CSS) companies.  CSS companies that sign up to or adopt the Framework are bound to a series of commitments for delivering on climate action. The Framework also outlines targeted approaches, informed by existing best practices, for implementing solutions that address the sector’s climate action objectives. What’s behind the Framework? CSS companies have an important role in achieving the Government’s 2030 climate action targets as set out in the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Act 2021 and Climate Action Plan (CAP) 2021. A robust climate action strategy includes objectives for both mitigating and adapting to climate change. The public sector is uniquely positioned to lead by example, implementing changes that help Ireland achieve its climate action objectives and transition to a low-carbon and climate-neutral economy and society.  By taking charge, upholding commitments and successfully delivering on climate action strategies, public sector bodies can show other industries that meeting the Government’s climate action targets is achievable. CSS companies must fund the cost of meeting the commitments from their own resources. The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland’s (SEAI) public-sector monitoring and reporting system will measure the impact of their climate actions. Five commitments for CSS companies The five commitments within the Framework map onto the three pillars outlined in the Public Sector Leading by Example sections of the CAP 2019 and 2021 – measurement of carbon footprint, green public procurement and carbon pricing in capital evaluation.  The two additional commitments relate specifically to climate actions for corporate environments, focusing on the governance of climate action objectives and financial disclosures. Commitment 1: Governance of Climate Action Objectives What is it: Oversight at board level and integration of climate action objectives in the company’s strategic business planning. Why it matters: Having board-level oversight offers a clue about the importance of climate-related issues to an organisation as a whole. Buy-in and involvement at this level sends a signal to the entire company that meaningful climate action is integral to the company’s strategic direction. The board’s approval and monitoring of the resulting sustainability strategies ensures they are progressing appropriately, putting the organisation on track to meet its shorter-term climate-related benchmarks and ultimately achieve its long-term climate action objectives. Commitment 2: Emissions Measurement and Reduction Target What is it: Formal adoption of government emission reduction targets for the public sector and the SEAI measurement methodology. Why it matters:  Having a reporting structure to capture, compare and monitor carbon emissions over time is critical for driving accountability in reducing emissions.  At a minimum, organisations should be measuring their Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions; however, the reporting requirements for Scope 3 emissions are set to increase, so companies can get ahead of the curve by beginning to report on these emissions now.   CAP 2021 requires that public sector bodies reduce their emissions by 51 percent. That’s an ambitious and challenging target, and the challenge will likely increase as the types of emissions included 'in scope' continue to expand. Commitment 3: Measuring and Valuing Emissions in Investment Appraisals What is it: Having investment decision-makers incorporate the value of carbon emissions in their decision-making parameters. Why it matters: Project appraisals for public capital investments need to consider fossil-fuel consumption to avoid any expenditures on long-term projects that have a commitment to or dependency on fossil fuels.  Greenhouse gas emission targets are legally binding and challenging to meet, so investment decision-makers need to take a project’s potential carbon emissions into account before they make a financial investment. Using carbon pricing during appraisals allows decision-makers to fully understand the cost that society will bear for a project’s emissions.  As a result, they can appreciate the climate consequences of their investment decisions and make better, more informed choices when presented with different options. The 2019 Public Spending Code sets out current carbon pricing; however, the Code is likely to be updated again to estimate the cost of achieving CAP 2021’s enhanced target of a 51 percent emission reduction. CSS companies must be in full compliance with this code year on year. Commitment 4: Circular Economy and Green Procurement What is it: The promotion of circular economy measures and implementation of green procurement processes. Why it matters: A circular economy reduces waste by maintaining the value of products and materials for as long as possible. Forty-five percent of carbon emissions come from the production of goods, so implementing a circular economy is a necessity for meeting emission reduction targets. The Whole-of-Government Circular Economy Strategy sets out Ireland’s transition plan to a circular economy. The public sector will play a leading role in this transition by implementing green procurement and circular economy practices. The Office of Government Procurement (OGP) has updated its procurement frameworks to align with these practices, providing guidance to public and semi-state bodies on how to meet their need for goods, services, works and utilities with solutions while simultaneously considering the total economic and environmental cost – from cradle to grave – of a solution. CSS companies should engage with the OGP and central purchasing bodies to facilitate their transition to green procurement practices. Commitment 5: Climate-related Disclosures in Financial Reporting What is it: Compliance with a relevant and appropriate climate-related disclosures framework within a defined time frame. Why it matters: Companies, including CSS companies, must become more transparent and aggressive about reporting climate-related information. Transparency is key for building and maintaining stakeholder trust and preventing reputational damage. Investors, regulators, purchasers and other stakeholders increasingly want access to this climate-related information because these insights often have implications for their own climate-related decision-making. Regulatory authorities and governments continue to update and strengthen their environmental reporting requirements. For instance, the new EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive requires that companies operating in the EU report sustainability disclosures across several topics related to environmental and societal issues. CSS companies can keep pace with such regulations by adhering to a robust and appropriate climate-related disclosures framework.

Ireland’s urban growth demands sustainable development. As we transition to a green future, our focus must be on modernising regulations, energy resilience, R&D and public-private partnerships, says Robert Costello Ireland’s urbanisation has been rapid: in 1969, half of the population lived in rural areas, and urbanisation is expected to reach 75 percent by 2050. In recent decades, urbanisation combined with general population growth and an economic boom has dramatically increased the footprint of Ireland’s cities. Much of this growth occurred without due regard for sustainable development. As Ireland sets out on a green transition, we must focus on making our cities sustainable. Like the broader economy, Ireland’s cities run largely on fossil fuels. According to the United Nations, cities consume about 78 percent of the world’s energy, accounting for more than 60 percent of greenhouse gas emissions. Transport accounts for almost 18 percent of total emissions in Ireland, and nearly all (94 percent) of these emissions come from road transport. Ireland has among the longest commute times in Europe, with many commuting into and around cities. Ireland’s buildings are among the hardest to heat in Europe, with heat loss rates (U-values) three times those of Sweden. With poor heat retention and a relatively high reliance on solid fuels and oil, Irish buildings have the highest emissions in Europe. Net zero emissions commitments of Ireland and the EU The European Union is committed to achieving a 55 percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 and net zero emissions by 2050. Ireland has committed to reducing emissions by 50 percent by 2030 and achieving net zero emissions by 2050. Considering Ireland’s starting point relative to many of our European counterparts, significant action is required across the economy and society. By implementing initiatives across the following four pathways, Ireland’s urban areas can become more sustainable and resilient to climate change. 1. Modernise regulations Having the funding and finance to complete the green transition is necessary, but it is not sufficient: the regulatory environment must enable the required investment. Ireland’s regulatory regime has been slow to respond to the needs of those working towards Ireland’s net zero ambition. Green hydrogen (hydrogen produced from renewable energy) will have a key role to play in decarbonising the country’s hard-to-electrify sectors. This must be underpinned by a national hydrogen strategy that reviews existing regulations, considers where changes are required, and signals to the market the direction of travel in terms of the development of this vital sector. While the Government has consulted on a hydrogen strategy, the consultation report has yet to be published. An ambitious hydrogen strategy will go hand in hand with plans to develop offshore wind farms on Ireland’s west coast, allowing the country to become an energy exporter. 2. Plan for energy resilience and sustainability According to Engineers Ireland, Ireland faces an energy trilemma in which we must meet our energy needs while ensuring that we (i) increase sustainable energy production, (ii) keep our energy supply secure, and (iii) maintain affordability. Diversity of supply and investment in infrastructure, such as interconnectors and energy storage, are essential in overcoming this trilemma. 3. Invest in research and development We cannot build the world of tomorrow without research and development (R&D) today. We must therefore recognise the role of R&D within Ireland in making our green transition possible. As an international hub for technology firms, Ireland has the potential to make digitalisation a core part of how we decarbonise our economy, building smart cities and communities. Combined public and private investment in digitalisation R&D will transform our economy. 4. Rethink public-private partnerships Public-private partnerships (PPPs) are a very useful method of contracting to deliver infrastructure. In Ireland, they have been successfully deployed to develop our motorway network, build schools and now deliver much-needed social housing. They involve a lot of upfront work, de-risking projects and ensuring that the assets built are robust and well-maintained into the future. They also encourage more private sector involvement in infrastructure, bringing new technology and innovation into projects. In addition, PPPs allow governments and public bodies to retain ownership of the infrastructure assets, an essential feature for long-term public ownership. Rethinking PPPs involves broadening the areas in which this model can be deployed to help realise our net zero ambition. Areas where the model (or a variation of the model) can be deployed include district heating, battery storage, offshore grid infrastructure, bus and train fleets, electric vehicle (EV) charging, sustainable buildings and port infrastructure. On the (path)way to a better future Cities, big and small, can set out on clean-energy pathways. Each pathway requires working with various stakeholders, including some with competing needs. These stakeholders include regulators, power generators, power transmission and distribution companies, industry and consumers. Only by laying the proper groundwork can people be brought on board and positive outcomes maximised. Stakeholder engagement is all the more essential in the case of Ireland’s cities, which have less administrative and financial autonomy than cities such as Paris or Berlin – Ireland has the lowest level of local autonomy in the European Union. With a population that continues to grow rapidly and become more urban, Ireland must seize the opportunity to build more sustainable cities. A successful and sustainable green transition requires bringing people on board and embracing the technology that will enable shorter, cleaner commutes, warmer homes and a cleaner environment. Outlining and committing to clean energy pathways enables the public and private sectors to put the resources in place and build the necessary capacity to deliver the required investment in our cities and towns. Robert Costello is Leader in Capital Projects & Infrastructure Practice at PwC

  In this week’s Sustainability/ESG bulletin, read how environmental taxes in Ireland raised €4.5 billion in 2022 compared to capital taxes which raised €2.35 billion in the same period. In addition, we cover the launch of a multimillion pound project to explore the potential for geothermal energy in Northern Ireland, updates from Europe, new sustainability resources that are available for businesses, as well as the usual roundup of articles, podcasts and events. Environmental taxes bring in €4.5 billion in 2022 The Central Statistics Office (CSO) has published its latest release of environment taxes for 2022. The statistics indicate that environment-related taxes accounted for 4 percent of total taxes in 2022, amounting to €4.5 billion (compared to capital taxes which represented just under 2.9 percent in the same period amounting to €2.35 billion). Carbon taxes increased by 22 percent in 2022 compared to the same period in  2021, and amounted to €807 million. Energy taxes, which include transport fuels, accounted for 61 percent of all environment-related taxes in 2022. Transport taxes (including motor tax and vehicle registration tax) accounted for 39 percent of all environment-related taxes in 2022. Ireland’s progress on the UN Sustainable Development Goals Ireland has submitted its second Voluntary National Review (VNR) on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to the United Nations, assessing the country’s progress on actions to achieve Agenda 2030 and the SDGs. The VNR notes that while progress has been made, including fully achieving over 80 percent of the associated 169 targets, Ireland faces challenges in achieving the goals. A report published separately by Concern Ireland states that businesses, particularly SMEs, are a cohort in particular need of support in delivering on sustainability goals, and highlighted the tensions between the business sector’s drive for profit and the need to address the pressing climate and sustainability challenges. Separately, the  Minister for Transport, Eamon Ryan TD, announced the publication of the Renewable Transport Fuel Policy 2023-2025, which aims to bring Ireland closer to sustainable transport goals. Meanwhile, the EPA launched a new Food Waste Charter, calling on all businesses and State Agencies operating across the food supply chain to sign up and commit to reducing food waste to help Ireland meet its commitments to halve food waste by 2030 under UN Sustainable Development Goal 12.3. Further information about what the UN SDGs mean for accountants can be found in Chartered Accountants Ireland’s Sustainability for Accountants. Irish Government consultations on sustainability  The Department of the Environment, Communications and Climate Action (DECC) is inviting contributions to a number of consultations including: a call for expert evidence to support and inform the preparation of the Climate Action Plan 2024, which is due for publication later this year. The closing date for responses is 14 July, and submissions can be made online through a consultation platform.   a consultation on the Department’s Research and Innovation Strategy. The accompanying consultation document sets out the background and context for research and innovation in DECC, including an overview of current research and innovation activities supported. The closing date for receipt of submissions via the EU Survey website is 11 August. Climate Conversation 2023, an online questionnaire seeking views on how Ireland can secure a sustainable future and become a climate resilient society. Inputs will feed into ongoing work on Climate Action Plan 2024, and the closing date for responses is 8 September. Northern Ireland Geothermal energy potential project launches A new multimillion pound project from the Northern Ireland Department for the Economy is set to explore the potential for geothermal energy in Northern Ireland, it was announced this week. The project designed to ‘unearth the heat beneath our feet’ aims to support how the region will decarbonise the energy sector in pursuit of net zero carbon targets by 2050.  Geothermal energy is the heat generated and stored in the Earth and is a source of affordable, low-carbon, renewable energy. Air quality statistics - Europe The European Environment Agency (EEA) has published provisional data on CO2 emissions from new passenger cars and vans registered in Europe in 2022 which show that average carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from new cars and vans in Europe dropped in 2022 for the third year running. The main driver of this trend was a continued growth in the share of electric car and van registrations. A separate report found that key air pollutants monitored under EU law continued to decline across most EU Member States, maintaining a trend since 2005. Separately the European Parliament’s Environment Committee adopted its position to improve air quality in the EU and to create a cleaner and healthier environment, setting stricter 2030 limit and target values for several pollutants to ensure that air quality in the EU is not harmful to human health, natural ecosystems and biodiversity. This news comes as the EU Commission this week adopted annual emissions allocations for Member States for 2023, 2024 and 2025, setting the maximum level of greenhouse gas emissions that each Member State can generate per year in the sectors covered by the European Union’s Effort Sharing legislation, aligning the allocations with the recently agreed, more ambitious national targets for 2030. These will collectively cut the EU’s greenhouse gas emissions in the Effort Sharing sectors by 40 percent when compared with 2005 levels (the previous 2030 target was a 30 percent reduction). Climate change, security and defence  - Europe The European Commission and the High Representative have adopted a Joint Communication laying out how the EU will address the growing impact of climate change and environmental degradation in the fields of peace, security, and defence. The communication sets out four main priorities around planning, operations and partnerships, and approximately 30 actions to deliver on them, making clear the connection between climate and environmentally induced instability and resource scarcity that can be instrumentalised by armed groups and organised crime networks, among others. Nature restoration law There was no majority amongst MEPs on the Environment Committee for the Commission’s proposal, as amended, for a Nature Restoration Law. The regulation on nature restoration was proposed by the Commission in 2022 as part of the European Green Deal to contribute to the long-term recovery of damaged nature across the EU’s land and sea areas and to achieve EU climate and biodiversity objectives. Separately the Commission is planning to mobilise an additional €430 million of EU funding for EU farmers, including €9.5 million for Irish farmers, impacted by adverse climatic events, high input costs, and diverse market and trade-related issues. New sustainability guidance for business Irish business group Ibec has launched ‘Climate Action: A toolkit for business’, in collaboration with Accenture. The toolkit provides businesses with the information they need for their climate action journey and provides practical guidance on how to develop an enduring climate action strategy.   Business in the Community Ireland has also recently published its 2023 Sustainability Handbook which aims to help develop a common understanding of the role of business as powerful agents for good in bringing about a low-carbon economy.   The Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) has issued new supplier engagement guidance which aims to enable businesses to accelerate their decarbonisation efforts and support companies to engage their supply chains to set science-based targets.   The World Wide Fund For Nature (WWF) has issued a short explainer on the implications for business from recent climate science, describing how businesses can invest in solutions and innovations that can protect both the environment and nature, cut emissions and “unleash business ingenuity at every level with their customers, investors and employees”.   A summary has been published by the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) of a recent 2023 EU Green Week event where global industry leaders, experts and finance professionals explored the crucial role of accountancy in driving sustainability. The event addressed the relevant skills and capacity building needed to empower accountants, and IFAC’s summary also includes useful resources and links to further information. Technical update (From our colleagues in Professional Accounting) The International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) issued its inaugural standards - IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 - on 26 June 2023.The standards create a common language for disclosing the effect of climate-relates risks and opportunities in companies. See also webcasts on IFRS S1 and how IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 work together, ISSB’s an article “Ten things to know about the first ISSB Standards” responses from EFRAG and IFAC and the UK Endorsement Board (UKEB) draft comment letter relating to the ISSB’s recent Request for Information to inform its initial two-year work plan. Comments are requested by 23 July 2023. The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment is holding a webinar on the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive on Tuesday 4 July at 3pm. The webinar will provide an update on the policy decisions taken following the recent public consultation on member state options, and an update on its transposition plans.  Glossary update The Chartered Accountants Ireland sustainability glossary has been updated to include the All-Ireland Pollinator Plan, the Business for Biodiversity Platform, Business for Nature, ENCORE, the Wildlife Habitat Council (WHC) and the WWF – Biodiversity Risk Filter. Did you know? People around the world are preparing for Plastic Free July. Participants are taking their own small steps by looking at the plastics in their lives and choosing one or two items to switch. A free 31 Days of Plastic Free Choices calendar is available to download, with ideas for how to reduce single-use plastic waste at work, home, school, and in the community. Podcast The Explainer: What is hydrogen power, and could it replace coal, oil, and gas? James Carton, assistant professor in Sustainable Energy with DCU and an academic advisor to the United Nations on hydrogen, joins us on this week’s podcast to discuss this lesser spotted form of energy. How do you make it? Where could it be used instead of fossil fuels? Could it be part of a clean energy future, or does it amount to simply greenwashing? (27 mins) ‘You can’t decarbonize without digitization, you can’t increase digitization without data centres’  Ciaran Hancock is joined by Irish Times Business Reporter Ian Curran, Director of Cloud Infrastructure Ireland, Michael McCarthy and Energy Researcher at UCC, Paul Deane to discuss the impact of data centres on Ireland’s carbon emissions goals (32 mins) Articles   Accounting for Sustainability (A4S) has published a piece about bring finance mindset into sustainability reporting How to tell a good ESG story (ICAEW Insights) New rules aim to clamp down on corporate greenwashing (Reuters) The crucial role of auditors and accountants in the climate change fight (Accountancy Age) Five Takeaways From the Paris Summit to Fix Global Climate Finance (Bloomberg) EU Banks Expand Risk Scenarios They Face From Climate Change  (Bloomberg) Greenwashing firms and public entities face growing threat of litigation (Irish Times) EU regulators step up scrutiny on greenwashing (ICAEW Insights) CSRD: striving for consistent and quality sustainability assurance engagements across the EU. Accountancy Europe is inviting key stakeholders to exchange on their expectations for assurance engagements, the practical implications of the CSRD assurance requirement and the role of the assurance standard. This event is in person and by invitation only. For more information, contact events@accountancyeurope.eu. 5 July Network for Chartered Accountants working on ESG projects Are you a Chartered Accountant working in ESG or working on ESG-related projects? Would you like an opportunity to engage with other Chartered Accountants working in this space to share insights, challenges and opportunities? Chartered Accountant now has a network to allow members working in sustainability/ESG to meet and discuss all matters of interest re ESG and accounting. 3rd or 4th Wednesday of every month Next: 26 July, 2023  14.00-15.00/30 Chartered Accountant House/Teams If you would like to attend please email sustainability@charteredaccountants.ie   You can find information, guidance and supports to understand sustainability and meet the challenges it presents in our online Sustainability Centre.