• Current students
      • Student centre
        Enrol on a course/exam
        My enrolments
        Exam results
        Mock exams
        Learning Hub data privacy policy
      • Course information
        Students FAQs
        Student induction
        Course enrolment information
        F2f student events
        Key dates
        Book distribution
        Timetables
        FAE elective information
      • Exams
        Exam Info: CAP1
        E-assessment information
        Exam info: CAP2
        Exam info: FAE
        Access support/reasonable accommodation
        Extenuating circumstances
        Timetables for exams & interim assessments
        Interim assessments past papers & E-Assessment mock solutions
        Committee reports & sample papers
        Information and appeals scheme
        JIEB: NI Insolvency Qualification
      • CA Diary resources
        Mentors: Getting started on the CA Diary
        CA Diary for Flexible Route FAQs
      • Admission to membership
        Joining as a reciprocal member
        Conferring dates
        Admissions FAQs
      • Support & services
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contracts
        CASSI
        Student supports and wellbeing
        Audit qualification
        Diversity and Inclusion Committee
    • Students

      View all the services available for students of the Institute

      Read More
  • Becoming a student
      • About Chartered Accountancy
        The Chartered difference
        What do Chartered Accountants do?
        5 Reasons to become a Chartered Accountant
        Student benefits
        School Bootcamp
        Third Level Hub
        Study in Northern Ireland
        Events
        Blogs
        Member testimonials 2022
        Become a Chartered Accountant podcast series
      • Entry routes
        College
        Working
        Accounting Technicians
        School leavers
        Member of another body
        International student
        Flexible Route
        Training Contract
      • Course description
        CAP1
        CAP2
        FAE
        Our education offering
      • Apply
        How to apply
        Exemptions guide
        Fees & payment options
        External students
      • Training vacancies
        Training vacancies search
        Training firms list
        Large training firms
        Milkround
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contract
        Interview preparation and advice
        The rewards on qualification
        Tailoring your CV for each application
        Securing a trainee Chartered Accountant role
      • Support & services
        Becoming a student FAQs
        Who to contact for employers
        Register for a school visit
    • Becoming a
      student

      Study with us

      Read More
  • Members
      • Members Hub
        My account
        Member subscriptions
        Annual returns
        Application forms
        CPD/events
        Member services A-Z
        District societies
        Professional Standards
        Young Professionals
        Careers development
        Diversity and Inclusion Committee
      • Members in practice
        Going into practice
        Managing your practice FAQs
        Practice compliance FAQs
        Toolkits and resources
        Audit FAQs
        Other client services
        Practice Consulting services
        What's new
      • In business
        Networking and special interest groups
        Articles
      • Overseas members
        Home
        Key supports
        Tax for returning Irish members
        Networks and people
      • Public sector
        Public sector news
        Public sector presentations
      • Member benefits
        Member benefits
      • Support & services
        Letters of good standing form
        Member FAQs
        AML confidential disclosure form
        Institute Technical content
        TaxSource Total
        The Educational Requirements for the Audit Qualification
        Pocket diaries
        Thrive Hub
    • Members

      View member services

      Read More
  • Employers
      • Training organisations
        Authorise to train
        Training in business
        Manage my students
        Incentive Scheme
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contracts
        Securing and retaining the best talent
        Tips on writing a job specification
      • Training
        In-house training
        Training tickets
      • Recruitment services
        Hire a qualified Chartered Accountant
        Hire a trainee student
      • Non executive directors recruitment service
      • Support & services
        Hire members: log a job vacancy
        Firm/employers FAQs
        Training ticket FAQs
        Authorisations
        Hire a room
        Who to contact for employers
    • Employers

      Services to support your business

      Read More
☰
  • The Institute
☰
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Students
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Archive
  • Podcasts
  • Contact us
Search
View Cart 0 Item
  • Home/
  • Accountancy Ireland/
  • Articles/
  • Comment/
  • Latest News

Comment

Conflicts of interest

Jun 01, 2018
Many corporate governance mechanisms are symbolic rather than substantive, which only serves to worsen the malaise.

Corporate governance reforms have placed much focus on director independence. While director independence and conflicts of interest are related, the finer subtle points of handling conflicts of interest have received less attention.

Conflicts of interest are pervasive in corporate governance – conflicts between corporate objectives versus other objectives. Directors’ duty is to look after the interests of their company, not their own personal interests. Directors’ personal interests may conflict with the company’s interests, which can compromise good corporate governance.

Conflicts of interest can occur between directors and their company, shareholders and their company, shareholders and directors, parent companies and their subsidiaries, parties in a joint venture, government ministers and state companies, and stakeholders (customers, employees) who are also board members. They are a feature of family businesses, where there may be conflict between family interests and business objectives.

Mechanisms are in place to manage conflicts of interest, such as declaring conflicts of interest at the start of board meetings, directors leaving board meetings when an agenda item with which they have a conflict is being discussed and not circulating papers/minutes to directors concerning the conflicted issue. So-called “Chinese walls” are another mechanism, acting as a barrier to the exchange of information between conflicted parties.

Such mechanisms may work when the conflict is occasional but, in my opinion, can rarely operate successfully where the conflict is systematic and pervasive. Like many corporate governance mechanisms, they may operate in a symbolic rather than substantive manner. Take, for example, the following anecdote I heard: an item arises at a board meeting and the chairman says: “Seán, should you step out of the meeting?” At this point, the whole board burst out laughing!

Disclosure is the most popular mechanism for handling conflicts of interest. Disclosure offers something to everyone. It is a symbolic rather than substantive response to the problem. Disclosure of a conflict of interest offers the recipient the opportunity of discounting advice from a conflicted party, thereby helping the recipient make better decisions. But there is evidence that recipients may not sufficiently discount the biased advice. 

Disclosure may have the added pernicious effect of legitimising bias from the conflicted party. Thus, rather than mitigating the risks from the conflict of interest, it may exacerbate those risks. This perspective prompted the following comment in the New Yorker: “Transparency is well and good, but accuracy and objectivity are even better. Wall Street doesn’t have to keep confessing its sins. It just has to stop committing them.”

Disclosure has minimal impact on the status quo for the conflicted parties. For example, disclosing a connection on a board of directors is better than the more substantive action of resigning from the board to address the conflict.

An additional insidious consequence of conflicts of interest in boardrooms is their effect on decision-making. The Financial Reporting Council’s Guidance on Board Effectiveness identifies the risk of conflicts of interest distorting judgement and introducing unconscious bias into decision-making. Research has shown that the mechanisms to manage conflicts of interest are no match for unconscious bias.
Handling conflicts of interest requires different types of thinking, along the lines of Daniel Kahneman’s Thinking Fast and Slow. Academics have compared the automatic mental processes concerning self-interest as being fast, effortless, involuntary, not amenable to introspection; managing conflicts of interest, on the other hand, involves slow, effortful, voluntary introspection.

Shareholders appoint the directors at the annual general meeting. The law provides relatively little redress to shareholders where things go wrong due to the actions of directors. If shareholders appoint unsuitable persons as their directors, then they must bear the consequences. Shareholders need to take care not to appoint persons to the board that have systematic conflicts of interest with the company. I question the wisdom of appointing worker directors (especially elected worker directors) to state boards because of their conflict of interest to look after the best interests of the state entity versus to look after the best interests of their electorate with a view to being re-elected.

Substantial elimination of conflicts of interest is the first line of defence. It would help to also change the mindset of business from a self-interested individualistic culture, in favour of a pro-social good-of-society perspective.

Prof. Niamh Brennan is Michael MacCormac Professor of Management at UCD College of Business.

The latest news to your inbox

Useful links

  • Current students
  • Becoming a student
  • Knowledge centre
  • Shop
  • District societies

Get in touch

Dublin HQ

Chartered Accountants
House, 47-49 Pearse St,
Dublin 2, Ireland

TEL: +353 1 637 7200
Belfast HQ

The Linenhall
32-38 Linenhall Street, Belfast
Antrim BT2 8BG, United Kingdom.

TEL: +44 28 9043 5840

Connect with us

CAW Footer Logo-min
GAA Footer Logo-min
CARB Footer Logo-min
CCAB-I Footer Logo-min

© Copyright Chartered Accountants Ireland 2020. All Rights Reserved.

☰
  • Terms & conditions
  • Privacy statement
  • Event privacy notice
LOADING...

Please wait while the page loads.