• Current students
      • Student centre
        Enrol on a course/exam
        My enrolments
        Exam results
        Mock Exams 2020/21
        CAP1 essential documents
        CAP2 essential documents
        FAE essential documents
      • Course information
        Students FAQs
        Student induction
        Course enrolment information
        Key dates
        Book distribution
        Timetables
        FAE Elective Information
      • Exams
        Exam Info: CAP1
        E-assessment information
        Exam info: CAP2
        Exam info: FAE
        Reasonable accommodation and extenuating circumstances
        Timetables for exams & interim assessments
        Interim assessments past papers & E-Assessment mock solutions
        Main examination past papers
        Information and appeals scheme
        JIEB: NI Insolvency Qualification
      • CA Diary resources
        Mentors: Getting started on the CA Diary
        CA Diary for Flexible Route FAQs
      • Admission to membership
        Joining as a reciprocal member
        Conferring dates
        Admissions FAQs
      • Support & services
        Audit Qualification requirements
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contracts
        CASSI
        Student supports and wellbeing
        Learning Hub data privacy policy
    • Students

      View all the services available for students of the Institute

      Read More
  • Becoming a student
      • About Chartered Accountancy
        The Chartered difference
        What do Chartered Accountants do?
        5 Reasons to become a Chartered Accountant
        Student benefits
        School Bootcamp
        Chartered Connect
        Study in Northern Ireland
        Events
        Blogs
        Testimonials of Flexible route
      • Entry routes
        College
        Working
        Accounting Technicians
        School leavers
        Member of another body
        International student
        Flexible Route
        Training Contract
      • Course description
        CAP1
        CAP2
        FAE
        New education offering
      • Apply
        How to apply
        Exemptions guide
        Fees & payment options
        External students
      • Training vacancies
        Training vacancies search
        Training firms list
        Large training firms
        Milkround
        Training firms update details
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contract
        Interview preparation and advice
        The rewards on qualification
        Tailoring your CV for each application
        Securing a trainee Chartered Accountant role
      • Support & services
        Becoming a student FAQs
        Who to contact for employers
        Register for a school visit
    • Becoming a
      student

      Study with us

      Read More
  • Members
      • Members Hub
        My account
        Annual subscription fees
        Annual returns
        Application forms
        CPD/events
        Member services A-Z
        District societies
        Professional Standards
        Young Professionals
        Advocacy
        Careers development
      • In practice
        Going into practice
        Practice Matters
        Practice toolkits
        Members in practice committee
        Practice networks
        Helpsheets
        Compliance support
        Members' complaints adviser
        Free services
        Our approach
        Workshops and professional training with a difference
        Abhaile Scheme
        Practice News webinars
        GDPR resources for practices
      • Overseas members
        Working abroad
        Working in Australia
        Overseas members news
        Tax for returning Irish members
      • In business
        Networking and special interest groups
        Articles
      • Public sector
        Public sector news
        Public sector presentations
      • Support & services
        Letters of good standing form
        FAQs for Chartered Accountants
        AML confidential disclosure form
        CHARIOT/Institute Technical content
        TaxSource
        Pocket diaries
    • Members

      View member services

      Read More
  • Employers
      • Training organisations
        Authorise to train
        Training in business
        Course enrolment information for firms
        Manage my students
        Incentive Scheme
        Recruitment to and transferring of training contracts
        Securing and retaining the best talent
        Tips on writing a job specification
      • Training
        In-house training
        Training tickets
      • Recruitment services
        Hire a qualified Chartered Accountant
        Hire a trainee student
      • Non executive directors recruitment service
      • Support & services
        Hire members: log a job vacancy
        Firm/employers FAQs
        Training ticket FAQs
        Authorisations
        Hire a room
        Who to contact for employers
    • Employers

      Services to support your business

      Read More
☰
  • Find a firm
  • Jobs
  • Login
☰
  • Home
  • Knowledge centre
  • Professional development
  • About us
  • Shop
  • News
Search
View Cart 0 Item

News

  • Home/
  • News
☰
  • News
  • News archive
    • 2020
    • 2019
  • RSS feeds store
  • Press releases
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2021
  • Newsletters
  • Press contacts
  • Media downloads
  • Podcasts Chartered Accountants Ireland
  • Budget day news

Put out that Candle

Jun 04, 2019

Sunday Business Post, 2 June 2019 
There’s a saying that it is better to light a candle than curse the darkness.  Judging from the outcome of the European and local elections where the relative success of Green party candidates is being taken as a strong hint to all of us to stop burning fossil fuels, is it now actually better to curse the candle than light the darkness?

There can be absolutely no doubt of the need to reduce the volumes of CO2 being released into the atmosphere because of how it disrupts climate.  However you don’t have to listen very carefully to hear the rattle of bandwagons being boarded as first the Taoiseach, followed by IBEC, leap on the notion of climate action.  As all too often happens, the nebulous sense of a need to take action of some description is crystallising around that most stable of all government policy weapons, a tax.

Some time ago, a developed Western economy put in place a relatively modest charge with the aim of better managing and supplying a limited natural resource which is used by everyone.  Expressions of public outrage at the charge went so far as to involve assaults on workers putting equipment in place to operate the levy.  After two years of unseemly political wrangling, the new charge was shamefacedly and quietly dropped.  Many people had ignored the charge; those more civic minded who had already paid it were refunded. 

This particular environmental tax was called “Water Charges” and of course they were introduced here.  Despite the utter rejection of that particular environmental charge, five years on there is almost a sense of eager anticipation surrounding carbon taxes.  So what has changed?

Maybe attitudes have changed because of our newly regained (relative) prosperity.  Last weekend the BBC published a striking map of Europe showing the countries where there had been a resurgence of support for Green politicians and where there had not.  The green tide only hit the shores of the north-western Europe, an area more prosperous than the south-east where the resurgence was not evident at all.

This suggests to me at least that environmental awareness is somewhere close to the top of the hierarchy of human needs, and only felt when more basic issues like job availability have been addressed.  If that is correct, this could be a better time to introduce carbon taxes towards moderating the impact of climate change, and that they might land better than the ill-fated water charges of five years ago. 

What is not clear though is what a carbon tax will be designed to achieve and if political thinking on the matter is aligned with the view of the ordinary taxpayer.  If a carbon tax is intended to change consumption patterns, alternatives to the use of high carbon taxed fuels must be provided.  There are already carbon taxes in place in Ireland, but how many of us choose our energy or transport needs by reference to the amount of carbon tax being levied?  How many of us actually know how much tax carbon tax is levied on petrol or diesel or home heating oil?  (It’s about 5 cents a litre and upwards depending on the fuel)

Even if we did, it wouldn't matter.  Many people don’t have access to a public transport infrastructure that offers a commuting choice.  Many householders will opt to buy expensive oil or gas rather than deal with the up-front cost of converting their home heating systems.  Nor can consumers decide not to heat their homes nor commute to work.  That would not be a change in consumption patterns; that would be just hardship.  Without choices, a “carbon tax” is simply a “tax”. 

There is little encouragement to be taken from recent carbon management initiatives at official level.  The 2017 National Mitigation Plan is anodyne recommending as it does a “targeted balance” (whatever that means) between Exchequer-supported expenditure and fiscal, taxation policies and regulation.  It is hard to extract any challenging proposal from it.  In March of this year the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Climate Action seems to have achieved consensus on the need for carbon taxes, but then spent its time wrangling over ensuring how few of us will end up paying them.  The Committee also managed to make tax recommendations while admitting that it did not have enough financial information to choose the best way to spend the extra tax.  That is not reassuring.

If setting a policy to raise additional carbon tax, government should remember the critical lesson of the water charges debacle.  Provide the environmentally sound alternatives first, and then charge for them later.  The Green tide could go out leaving the sharp edge of a carbon tax rock on which well-intentioned environmental policies will founder. 

Carbon taxes can either prompt changes to consumption patterns, or support more environmentally friendly options.  If they don’t, they will fail as a policy instrument.  Yet none of us can afford to keep the existing candles lit.  We need to fix our reliance on fossil fuels, but setting a tax to do so should be the last step in the process.  Decide on and carry out the infrastructure spending first.

Dr Brian Keegan is Director of Public Policy and Taxation at Chartered Accountants Ireland

The latest news to your inbox

Useful links

  • Current students
  • Becoming a student
  • Knowledge centre
  • Shop
  • District societies

Get in touch

Dublin HQ

Chartered Accountants
House, 47-49 Pearse St,
Dublin 2, Ireland

TEL: +353 1 637 7200
Belfast HQ

The Linenhall
32-38 Linenhall Street, Belfast
Antrim BT2 8BG, United Kingdom.

TEL: +44 28 9043 5840

Connect with us

Something wrong?

Is the website not looking right / working right for you?
Browser support
CAW Footer Logo-min
GAA Footer Logo-min
CCAB-I Footer Logo-min

© Copyright Chartered Accountants Ireland 2020. All Rights Reserved.

☰
  • Terms & conditions
  • Privacy statement
  • Event privacy notice
  • Sitemap
LOADING...

Please wait while the page loads.